Bad and doubtful debts are an unavoidable aspect of conducting business, especially in industries where credit sales form a large portion of revenue. While extending credit can increase sales and build customer relationships, it also exposes a company to the risk of non-payment. When some customers fail to pay their debts due to insolvency, disputes, or other financial constraints, these receivables must be accounted for properly to maintain the integrity of financial statements. Proper accounting treatment of bad and doubtful debts ensures that the company’s financial position, performance, and cash flows are presented fairly and in compliance with international accounting standards such as IFRS 9 (Financial Instruments) and IAS 1 (Presentation of Financial Statements). This article provides a detailed explanation of bad and doubtful debts, their causes, significance, and their accounting treatment within financial reporting frameworks.
1. What Are Bad and Doubtful Debts?
Definition
- Bad Debt: A debt that is confirmed as irrecoverable and must be written off from the books. This happens when it becomes certain that the debtor will not make payment, such as in the event of bankruptcy or liquidation.
- Doubtful Debt: A debt that is uncertain in recoverability — it may or may not be collectible in the future. These debts are not written off immediately but are instead estimated and provided for as a precaution.
Causes of Bad and Doubtful Debts
- Customer Insolvency or Bankruptcy: When customers become financially incapable of settling their obligations.
- Fraud or Intentional Non-Payment: Some debtors may deliberately avoid repayment.
- Poor Credit Assessment: Inadequate evaluation of customers’ creditworthiness before extending credit terms.
- Disputes Over Goods or Services: Unresolved product defects, service failures, or contract disagreements may lead to non-payment.
- Macroeconomic Factors: Recessions, inflation, or sudden economic shocks can affect customers’ ability to pay on time.
While some degree of bad debt is inevitable, effective credit control policies and provisions for doubtful debts help businesses anticipate and mitigate their financial impact.
2. The Importance of Recognizing Bad and Doubtful Debts
Recognizing bad and doubtful debts is essential for ensuring that financial statements present a realistic view of a company’s financial position. According to IFRS 9, businesses must estimate and account for expected credit losses (ECL) rather than waiting for actual default. This proactive approach provides investors and management with a more accurate understanding of the company’s exposure to credit risk.
- Accurate Financial Reporting: Ensures accounts receivable reflect their true collectible value, avoiding overstatement of assets.
- Improved Risk Management: Identifying doubtful debts early allows management to control and limit exposure to further losses.
- Compliance with Accounting Standards: IFRS 9 and GAAP require recognition of expected losses even before they materialize.
- Enhanced Decision-Making: Reliable financial data allows for informed decisions regarding credit policies, pricing, and financing.
In essence, recognizing bad and doubtful debts prevents distortion of earnings and ensures prudent presentation of financial performance.
3. Accounting Treatment of Bad Debts
Bad debts are recognized as an expense when it becomes certain that a customer will not pay. Writing off bad debts ensures that receivables on the balance sheet represent only amounts expected to be collected.
A. Writing Off Bad Debts
When a debt is confirmed as uncollectible, it is written off by transferring the amount from accounts receivable to bad debt expense.
Journal Entry:
Debit: Bad Debt Expense Credit: Accounts Receivable
Example: A customer who owes $2,000 declares bankruptcy, and the debt is determined to be irrecoverable.
Debit: Bad Debt Expense $2,000 Credit: Accounts Receivable $2,000
This entry removes the amount from the company’s receivables, ensuring that only collectible balances remain. Under IFRS 9, such recognition represents a credit loss event, where objective evidence confirms the impairment of a financial asset.
B. Recovery of a Written-Off Bad Debt
Occasionally, a debt previously written off may be recovered. In such cases, the recovery is recorded as income in the current period.
Journal Entry:
Debit: Cash/Bank Credit: Bad Debt Recovered (Income)
Example: A company recovers $500 from a debtor whose account was written off six months earlier.
Debit: Cash/Bank $500 Credit: Bad Debt Recovered $500
The recovery improves profitability and cash flow but does not alter prior financial statements. It is recognized in the period of receipt as “Other Income.”
4. Accounting Treatment of Doubtful Debts
Doubtful debts represent uncertain receivables that may not be collected in full. Instead of writing them off immediately, companies create a provision (or allowance) for doubtful debts based on estimated losses.
A. Creating a Provision for Doubtful Debts
This provision acts as a reserve against potential bad debts, ensuring prudent financial reporting in accordance with the conservatism principle.
Journal Entry:
Debit: Bad Debt Expense Credit: Provision for Doubtful Debts
Example: A business estimates that 5% of its $50,000 receivables may be uncollectible.
Provision = $50,000 × 5% = $2,500
Debit: Bad Debt Expense $2,500 Credit: Provision for Doubtful Debts $2,500
The provision reduces reported profit and appears as a deduction from accounts receivable in the balance sheet, showing the net realizable value of receivables.
B. Writing Off a Debt from the Provision
If a specific doubtful debt is later confirmed as bad, it is written off using the provision account rather than creating a new expense.
Journal Entry:
Debit: Provision for Doubtful Debts Credit: Accounts Receivable
Example: Out of a $2,500 provision, one customer defaults on $1,000.
Debit: Provision for Doubtful Debts $1,000 Credit: Accounts Receivable $1,000
This entry utilizes the existing provision, ensuring no double-counting of expenses. The remaining provision continues to cover future doubtful debts.
IFRS 9 Context: Under the expected credit loss (ECL) model, businesses estimate losses based on probability-weighted scenarios considering historical data, current conditions, and forward-looking information.
5. The Impact of Bad and Doubtful Debts on Financial Statements
A. Income Statement
- Bad debt expense and provision for doubtful debts are recorded as operating expenses, reducing net income.
- Recoveries of bad debts are recognized as “Other Income.”
B. Balance Sheet
- Bad debts directly reduce accounts receivable.
- Provisions for doubtful debts are deducted from gross receivables, showing the expected realizable value.
- High provisions may indicate greater credit risk exposure or poor customer vetting processes.
C. Cash Flow Statement
- Uncollected debts reduce operating cash inflows, tightening liquidity.
- Recoveries of bad debts improve cash flow but are classified as operating inflows.
- Effective debt management shortens the cash conversion cycle, enhancing working capital efficiency.
Proper provisioning protects investors and management from inflated profit figures by aligning reported results with economic reality.
6. Managing Bad and Doubtful Debts
A. Implementing Credit Control Policies
Businesses should establish robust credit policies outlining credit limits, payment terms, and customer evaluation procedures. Periodic reviews ensure that credit is granted only to financially sound clients.
B. Conducting Credit Checks
Before extending credit, conduct thorough assessments of customers using credit reports, bank references, or industry databases to evaluate their repayment capacity.
C. Regularly Reviewing Accounts Receivable
Frequent reconciliation of receivable ledgers helps identify overdue accounts and take timely action such as sending reminders or renegotiating terms.
D. Offering Discounts for Early Payment
Incentivizing early payment through cash discounts reduces outstanding receivables and minimizes the chance of defaults.
E. Using Debt Collection Strategies
When customers fail to respond, implement structured collection processes — from reminder notices to engaging third-party collection agencies or legal proceedings. Some companies also insure receivables through trade credit insurance to mitigate large losses.
These preventive measures reduce the likelihood of bad debts and preserve the liquidity essential for ongoing operations.
7. Differences Between Bad Debts and Doubtful Debts
| Aspect | Bad Debts | Doubtful Debts |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | Debts confirmed as uncollectible and written off permanently. | Debts that may become uncollectible but are still uncertain. |
| Accounting Treatment | Written off as an expense in the profit and loss account. | Estimated and recorded as a provision to anticipate possible loss. |
| Impact on Financial Statements | Reduces accounts receivable and net profit directly. | Shown as a deduction from receivables without directly reducing profit until confirmed as bad. |
| Possibility of Reversal | Cannot be reversed unless recovered; recoveries are treated as income. | Can be reversed if the debt is later settled or proven collectible. |
| Example | Customer declared bankrupt; $2,000 written off. | Customer payment delayed beyond 90 days; $1,000 estimated as doubtful. |
This differentiation is vital for both compliance and performance measurement — while bad debts affect profitability immediately, doubtful debts help in prudently anticipating potential losses.
Ensuring Financial Stability Through Proper Debt Management
Bad and doubtful debts represent a financial risk inherent in every business that extends credit. Although they cannot be completely eliminated, their impact can be mitigated through effective credit control, robust risk assessment, and consistent application of accounting standards. Proper accounting treatment — including timely recognition of bad debts, creation of adequate provisions, and disclosure in financial statements — ensures transparency and investor confidence.
Under IFRS 9’s Expected Credit Loss model, businesses must estimate potential defaults using historical patterns, current data, and forward-looking factors. This approach has transformed how entities assess receivable quality, making financial reporting more predictive and realistic. When combined with proactive credit management strategies — such as regular monitoring, credit insurance, and diversification of customer bases — companies can significantly reduce exposure to uncollectible accounts.
Ultimately, managing bad and doubtful debts is not merely an accounting task; it is a cornerstone of financial stability. By maintaining a balance between extending credit and safeguarding liquidity, organizations can protect profitability, strengthen stakeholder trust, and ensure sustainable long-term growth.
✓