The Machine Hour Method is a depreciation technique that allocates an asset’s cost based on actual usage rather than time. Instead of charging a fixed depreciation amount each year, this method calculates depreciation based on the number of hours a machine is used. This ensures a fairer distribution of expenses, particularly in businesses that rely on machinery for production. Below is a detailed example of how to calculate and record depreciation using the Machine Hour Method.
1. Understanding the Machine Hour Method
Before diving into calculations, it is important to understand why the Machine Hour Method exists and how it aligns with global accounting standards. Internationally, depreciation must reflect the “pattern in which the asset’s future economic benefits are expected to be consumed” (IAS 16 — Property, Plant and Equipment). The Machine Hour Method is one of the clearest illustrations of this principle because it assigns depreciation proportional to actual utilization, not time passing.
Formula:
The depreciation expense is calculated using the following formula:
Depreciation per Machine Hour = (Cost of Asset – Residual Value) ÷ Total Estimated Machine Hours
Annual Depreciation = Depreciation per Machine Hour × Machine Hours Used
- Cost of Asset: The original purchase price of the machine.
- Residual Value: The estimated scrap value at the end of the asset’s useful life.
- Total Estimated Machine Hours: The total operating hours the machine is expected to work.
- Machine Hours Used: The actual hours the machine was used during the accounting period.
These components are consistent with the requirements of IAS 16 (IFRS) and ASC 360 – Property, Plant, and Equipment (US GAAP), both of which require entities to estimate useful life and residual value and select a depreciation method that most accurately reflects consumption.
Why Use This Method?
In industries where usage varies greatly from month to month or year to year—such as manufacturing, printing, textile production, mining, construction, and automotive part machining—time-based depreciation produces distorted results. A machine that sits idle for six months but then operates 20 hours per day during peak season does not wear out evenly over time. The Machine Hour Method smooths this discrepancy by linking expense directly to wear and tear.
This is particularly important for management accounting because many businesses rely on depreciation to calculate machine cost per unit (a vital component of overhead allocation in activity-based costing). If depreciation is unrelated to usage, unit costs become inaccurate, potentially misleading pricing, budgeting, and capital budgeting decisions.
2. Example Scenario
Company’s Asset Details:
- A company purchases a machine for $60,000.
- The estimated residual value (scrap value) at the end of its life is $10,000.
- The total estimated working hours over its lifetime are 50,000 hours.
- The machine operates for 8,000 hours in the first year.
This scenario mirrors typical manufacturing environments, where machines often have clear estimations of total lifetime hours based on manufacturer specifications, engineering studies, or historical data. Many Japanese and German industrial equipment manufacturers provide detailed hour-based consumption patterns, allowing users to integrate such methods more precisely.
Step-by-Step Calculation:
Step 1: Calculate Depreciation Per Hour
Depreciation per Machine Hour = (60,000 – 10,000) ÷ 50,000
= $50,000 ÷ 50,000
= $1.00 per hour
Step 2: Calculate First-Year Depreciation
Annual Depreciation = $1.00 × 8,000
= $8,000
This result is simple to compute yet incredibly powerful when integrated into production cost analysis. Manufacturing organizations commonly include depreciation in machine overhead rates (used in job costing and process costing), and usage-based depreciation ensures that product costing remains fair and aligned with actual consumption.
3. Depreciation Schedule
Depreciation expense varies each year based on the machine’s usage.
| Year | Machine Hours Used | Depreciation Per Hour ($) | Depreciation Expense ($) | Accumulated Depreciation ($) | Book Value ($) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 8,000 | 1.00 | 8,000 | 8,000 | 52,000 |
| 2 | 10,000 | 1.00 | 10,000 | 18,000 | 42,000 |
| 3 | 7,500 | 1.00 | 7,500 | 25,500 | 34,500 |
| 4 | 12,000 | 1.00 | 12,000 | 37,500 | 22,500 |
| 5 | 12,500 | 1.00 | 12,500 | 50,000 | 10,000 (Residual Value) |
Interpretation of the Table
Notice how depreciation fluctuates with usage. This behavior is most consistent with actual economic consumption. From a financial analysis viewpoint, this method also affects:
- profit volatility — higher usage years show lower profit because depreciation is higher
- tax impact — if allowed under tax law, companies can reduce taxable income in high-usage years
- capital budgeting — understanding the cost behavior helps in calculating accurate internal machine rates
- maintenance planning — hours-based schedules align with engineering maintenance cycles
From an operational standpoint, companies that use machine-hour-based depreciation often also implement machine hour logbooks or IoT-based sensors that capture usage automatically. Modern ERP systems (SAP, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics) already integrate machine usage logs with accounting modules to automate depreciation entries.
4. Journal Entry for Machine Hour Depreciation
Each year, depreciation is recorded as follows:
Journal Entry:
Debit: Depreciation Expense
Credit: Accumulated Depreciation
Example (Year 1):
Debit: Depreciation Expense $8,000
Credit: Accumulated Depreciation $8,000
How Auditors Evaluate These Entries
External and internal auditors often examine machine hour logs, engineering reports, and asset usage data to verify depreciation accuracy. Under ISA 540 (Auditing Accounting Estimates), depreciation estimates are considered “significant accounting estimates,” meaning auditors must evaluate:
- reasonableness of useful life
- accuracy of residual value
- validity of recorded machine hours
- completeness of usage logs
- appropriate internal controls
Companies with weak controls over equipment usage may face audit findings, adjustments, or even restatements if depreciation has been materially misstated.
5. Impact on Financial Statements
A. Income Statement
- Depreciation expense is deducted from revenue, reducing net profit.
Under usage-based depreciation, income statement results may fluctuate year-to-year. Analysts evaluating earnings should understand that volatility may be driven by operational intensity, not inefficiency.
B. Balance Sheet
- The asset’s book value decreases annually.
This pattern mirrors actual deterioration. Assets used heavily lose value faster and reflect economic reality more accurately than straight-line depreciation would.
C. Cash Flow Statement
- Since depreciation is a non-cash expense, it is added back to net income in operating activities.
This means depreciation does not affect cash flows directly, but tax deductions (if permitted) may indirectly improve net cash flows.
6. Advantages of the Machine Hour Method
- More Accurate Expense Allocation: Depreciation reflects actual usage.
- Better for Production-Based Assets: Ideal for machines with variable workloads.
- Fair Cost Distribution: Years with higher usage show higher depreciation expenses.
Additional Strategic Advantages
- Improved Product Costing: Ensures machine overhead rates reflect true cost.
- Enhanced Budgeting: Managers can estimate maintenance and replacement more accurately.
- Better Capital Investment Decisions: Investors can evaluate ROI based on capacity usage.
- Supports Lean Manufacturing: Encourages efficient machine scheduling and utilization tracking.
7. Disadvantages of the Machine Hour Method
- Requires Detailed Record-Keeping: Businesses must track machine hours accurately.
- Not Suitable for All Assets: Only useful for machinery and equipment.
- Variable Depreciation Expense: Difficult to predict future costs.
Other Limitations
- Internal Controls Required: Weak logkeeping can lead to misstated depreciation.
- Tax Restrictions: Some jurisdictions disallow non-linear depreciation methods.
- Requires Technical Expertise: Engineers must estimate total useful hours accurately.
- Potential for Manipulation: Managers could influence profit by controlling machine-hour reporting.
8. Comparison with Other Depreciation Methods
| Depreciation Method | Basis of Calculation | Best Used For |
|---|---|---|
| Machine Hour Method | Depreciation based on actual hours used. | Machinery and production equipment. |
| Straight-Line Method | Equal depreciation each year. | Office buildings, furniture, equipment. |
| Reducing Balance Method | Higher depreciation in early years. | Computers, vehicles, technology. |
Expanded Comparison: IFRS Perspective
IAS 16 requires depreciation methods to be reviewed annually. Companies must switch methods if the consumption pattern changes. For example:
- A factory switching from manual operations to automated processes may find usage increases and shift to the Machine Hour Method.
- A company with idle equipment might switch back to straight-line for administrative simplicity.
US GAAP Comparison
- ASC 360 allows various depreciation methods as long as they reasonably match asset consumption.
- In practice, US companies often stick with straight-line for financial reporting but may use hour-based methods internally.
Practical Application of the Machine Hour Method
The Machine Hour Method is highly effective for businesses that rely on heavy machinery, ensuring that depreciation reflects actual wear and tear. This method aligns depreciation expenses with asset usage, making it a more accurate approach to cost allocation. However, businesses must maintain detailed records of machine hours to implement this method successfully.
Industries That Commonly Use This Method
- Manufacturing (metalworking, printing, plastic molding)
- Mining (drilling, extraction, crushing equipment)
- Construction (excavators, cranes, loaders)
- Transportation (aircraft engines measured by flight hours)
- Energy (power generation turbines)
Case Study: Automotive Parts Manufacturer
An automotive machining company uses CNC machines that operate irregular hours depending on customer demand. Using straight-line depreciation would overstate expenses during slow seasons and understate them during peak production. The Machine Hour Method ensures:
- accurate overhead allocation to each batch
- fair pricing of components
- precise capital replacement planning
Checklist for Successful Implementation
- Install machine hour counters or automated sensors
- Maintain logbooks validated by production supervisors
- Review useful life estimates annually
- Align maintenance schedules with hour-based depreciation
- Implement strong internal controls to prevent manipulation
Future Outlook: AI & Machine Hour Depreciation
Modern factories increasingly use AI-driven predictive maintenance systems. These systems do more than track hours—they assess operational stress, vibration, heat exposure, and mechanical load. In the coming years, depreciation may evolve from simple hour-based models to usage-intensity-based models, resulting in even more accurate cost allocation.
✓