When a business disposes of a fixed asset, it may result in a profit or a loss, depending on the difference between the asset’s Net Book Value (NBV) and its selling price. Proper accounting treatment ensures that the gain or loss is recorded correctly in financial statements. This article provides a step-by-step example of how to calculate and account for the profit or loss on disposal of a fixed asset.
Disposals of fixed assets occur frequently across industries and play a central role in how organizations manage their long-term resources. Whether a company upgrades machinery, liquidates assets to raise capital, restructures operations, or replaces outdated equipment, the accounting treatment must strictly follow standards such as IAS 16, IAS 36, and IFRS 5. Under US GAAP, ASC 360 governs the measurement, depreciation, impairment, and disposal of long-lived assets. Properly recognizing profit or loss ensures transparency, compliance, and accuracy in financial statements.
Beyond compliance, the disposal of fixed assets carries strategic, operational, tax, and financial implications. Organizations use fixed asset turnover ratios, capital budgeting metrics, and depreciation schedules to estimate asset performance over time. A disposal event reveals whether these estimates were realistic or overly optimistic. Significant profits may indicate conservative depreciation rates, while losses may suggest accelerated wear and tear, technological obsolescence, or weak resale markets.
Disposals also impact financial statements and key ratios. A disposal gain increases profit margins and equity, while a loss reduces earnings and asset values. Analysts often adjust these gains and losses to assess underlying performance, especially when disposals occur frequently as part of the organization’s business model (e.g., car rental companies, shipping fleets, or equipment leasing firms). Understanding profit or loss on disposal is therefore essential not only for accountants but also for auditors, managers, lenders, and investors.
1. Scenario: Disposal of Machinery
A company purchases machinery for $80,000 on January 1, 2020. The asset has:
- A useful life of 8 years
- A residual value of $8,000
- A depreciation method of Straight-Line
- After 3 years, the company sells the machine for $55,000
This scenario illustrates a typical disposal in which depreciation and expected useful life play a major role in determining NBV. Straight-line depreciation assumes equal consumption of economic benefits each year. However, real-world market value often diverges from book value due to economic conditions, technological change, and asset maintenance.
2. Step-by-Step Calculation
Step 1: Calculate Annual Depreciation
Annual Depreciation = (Cost – Residual Value) ÷ Useful Life
= ($80,000 – $8,000) ÷ 8
= $9,000 per year
This depreciation schedule reflects how the asset’s cost is expensed over time under IAS 16. Depreciation is a non-cash expense, reducing profit but not cash flows. Straight-line depreciation is simple and widely used, but organizations must ensure that the useful life and residual value estimates remain reasonable over time. If the machinery is used more intensively or becomes obsolete faster than expected, depreciation may no longer reflect its true economic consumption, requiring a revision under IAS 16 or an impairment test under IAS 36.
Step 2: Determine Net Book Value (NBV)
Accumulated Depreciation After 3 Years = 3 × $9,000
= $27,000
Net Book Value (NBV) = Cost – Accumulated Depreciation
= $80,000 – $27,000
= $53,000
This NBV represents the asset’s carrying amount for accounting purposes. However, NBV may not equal market value. Market value could be higher due to strong demand for used machinery or lower because of technological obsolescence. The comparison between NBV and selling price determines profit or loss on disposal, but it does not necessarily reflect economic performance.
Step 3: Compare Selling Price and NBV
- If Selling Price > NBV → Profit
- If Selling Price < NBV → Loss
Selling Price = $55,000
Profit on Disposal = Selling Price – NBV
= $55,000 – $53,000
= $2,000 (Profit)
The profit arises because the machine’s resale value exceeded its carrying amount. This may indicate conservative depreciation, good maintenance practices, favorable resale markets, or updated supply and demand conditions. Profit on disposal is classified under “Other Income” and does not form part of operating profit unless disposals are a core business activity.
3. Journal Entry for Profit on Disposal
Debit: Cash $55,000 (Proceeds from sale)
Debit: Accumulated Depreciation $27,000 (Remove accumulated depreciation)
Credit: Machinery Account $80,000 (Remove asset from books)
Credit: Gain on Disposal $2,000 (Recognize profit)
This entry removes the machine from the accounting records, eliminates related accumulated depreciation, and recognizes the gain. Internal auditors typically verify disposal entries for accuracy, ensuring consistency with supporting documents such as valuation reports, asset registers, and management approval forms.
4. Scenario: Disposal at a Loss
If the company sells the machine for $50,000 instead of $55,000:
Loss on Disposal = NBV – Selling Price
= $53,000 – $50,000
= $3,000 (Loss)
A loss indicates that the asset fetched less than its carrying amount. This may result from market downturns, mechanical issues, or overestimation of useful life. Losses reduce net income but often reflect realistic market dynamics. In many jurisdictions, disposal losses may provide tax-deductible benefits, reducing taxable income and improving cash flow.
5. Journal Entry for Loss on Disposal
Debit: Cash $50,000 (Proceeds from sale)
Debit: Accumulated Depreciation $27,000 (Remove accumulated depreciation)
Debit: Loss on Disposal $3,000 (Recognize loss)
Credit: Machinery Account $80,000 (Remove asset from books)
The loss is recorded as an expense. Analysts reviewing financial performance often adjust for disposal losses to isolate underlying operational performance. Frequent disposal losses may signal deeper issues such as poor asset management, inaccurate depreciation estimates, or maintenance deficiencies.
6. Impact on Financial Statements
Disposals affect all major financial statements, influencing liquidity, profitability, and financial position. Proper classification enhances clarity for stakeholders.
A. Balance Sheet
- The asset is removed from the fixed assets section.
- Cash increases from the sale proceeds.
- If a gain occurs, equity increases; if a loss occurs, equity decreases.
Fixed asset turnover ratios may improve after disposal if the company replaces old machinery with more efficient equipment. The reduction in total assets affects return on assets (ROA). Disposal gains increase retained earnings, while losses reduce them, directly altering equity values.
B. Income Statement
- A gain is recorded as non-operating income.
- A loss is recorded as an expense, reducing net profit.
Gains and losses are considered non-recurring unless asset disposal is part of core operations. Investors examining earnings quality may exclude these amounts when calculating adjusted profit or EBITDA. Misstating disposal gains can mislead users, making strong internal controls essential.
C. Cash Flow Statement
- The cash inflow from selling the asset is recorded in investing activities.
- The gain or loss is adjusted in operating activities since depreciation is a non-cash item.
This ensures that cash flows reflect actual operations, not capital transactions. Strong cash generation from asset disposals may indicate healthy resale markets but could also signal that the company is liquidating core assets to meet liquidity needs.
7. Best Practices for Asset Disposal
- Maintain accurate asset records and depreciation schedules.
- Assess market value before disposal to maximize gains.
- Ensure proper authorization and documentation for asset sales.
- Consider tax implications of asset disposal.
Best practices also include obtaining independent appraisals for high-value assets, evaluating potential trade-in options, reviewing impairment triggers before disposal, and adopting strong segregation of duties. Well-managed disposal processes improve capital allocation and prevent asset misappropriation.
Proper Accounting for Fixed Asset Disposal
When a business sells or disposes of a fixed asset, the correct accounting treatment ensures that financial statements reflect the transaction accurately. A profit or loss on disposal occurs based on the difference between the asset’s Net Book Value (NBV) and its selling price. Understanding how to calculate and record the disposal of fixed assets is essential for transparent financial reporting and informed decision-making.
Proper asset disposal accounting reinforces financial integrity, supports strategic asset management, and strengthens investor confidence. By adhering to IFRS/GAAP standards and maintaining strong internal controls, organizations can ensure compliance and demonstrate responsible stewardship of their long-term assets.
✓